Quick Answer

The amount of insurance (unit of coverage) you get for $9.95 depends on your age at the time of purchase. For example, a 50-year old person would get more coverage for $9.95 than a 65-year old.

Colonial Penn, a company with a longstanding reputation in the life insurance market, has been prominently known for its $9.95 Plan. This plan, heavily advertised across various media platforms, claims to offer affordable life insurance solutions, primarily targeting seniors. The cornerstone of this plan is its seemingly straightforward cost structure: a flat rate of $9.95 per month. At face value, this presents an enticing offer for individuals seeking financial security without straining their budgets.

However, beneath the surface of these appealing commercials and the allure of budget-friendly pricing, a wave of controversy and criticism has emerged. Questions have been raised about the actual value and effectiveness of the coverage provided by the $9.95 Plan. Critics argue that the commercials, while professionally produced and emotionally engaging, potentially obscure key details about the plan’s coverage limits and terms. These concerns stem from a growing discourse among consumers and industry experts who point out that the simplicity highlighted in the advertising may, in fact, mask complexities and limitations inherent in the policy.

Understanding the Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan

The Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan is a life insurance policy that has garnered significant attention due to its unique pricing strategy and targeted marketing campaigns. The hallmark of this plan is its fixed monthly premium of $9.95, which is presented as an affordable option for life insurance coverage. However, understanding the nuances of what this plan truly offers is crucial for potential policyholders.

Key Features of the Plan:

Fixed Premium: The most advertised feature is the unwavering monthly rate of $9.95, which does not increase with age or changes in health status.

Guaranteed Acceptance: Typically, this plan is offered without a medical exam or health questions, making it accessible to a wide range of applicants, including those with health concerns.

Age-Based Coverage: The amount of coverage one can purchase for $9.95 varies based on the policyholder’s age at the time of purchase. This is a critical point often not highlighted in commercials, where the focus is on the low premium rather than the coverage amount.

Comparison with Standard Life Insurance Policies: When juxtaposed with traditional life insurance policies, several differences become apparent:

Coverage Amount: Standard life insurance policies often offer a predetermined coverage amount, which is chosen by the policyholder based on their needs and budget. In contrast, the coverage amount in the Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan is directly tied to the age of the applicant, meaning older individuals receive significantly less coverage for the same premium compared to younger applicants.

Policy Type: The $9.95 Plan is typically a form of guaranteed acceptance whole life insurance, which differs from term life policies that offer coverage for a specified period and often come with higher coverage amounts.

Value for Money: While $9.95 appears economically attractive, the actual value must be evaluated in terms of the coverage provided. For many, especially older applicants, the coverage amount received per dollar spent might be lower compared to standard policies.

Underwriting Process: Traditional life insurance policies usually involve an underwriting process, including health examinations and questionnaires, to assess risk. The Colonial Penn plan circumvents this, often leading to higher premiums for lower coverage due to the assumed higher-risk pool.

In essence, the Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan offers a one-size-fits-all premium with variable coverage, primarily appealing to those who face challenges in securing traditional life insurance due to age or health issues. However, the trade-off for its accessible premium and guaranteed acceptance is often a lower coverage amount and potentially less value for money compared to standard life insurance policies. This analysis underscores the importance of comprehensively evaluating the plan’s features in relation to personal insurance needs and expectations.

Analysis of Colonial Penn’s Television Commercials

Colonial Penn’s $9.95 Plan has been widely publicized through a series of television commercials, employing marketing strategies that are both effective and emotive. These commercials often feature relatable scenarios and testimonials, aiming to connect with a target audience that values straightforward, budget-friendly insurance solutions. However, a closer examination reveals aspects that may potentially be misleading to consumers.

Overview of the Marketing Strategy:

Emotional Appeal: The commercials often utilize emotional storytelling, featuring scenarios that resonate with older audiences. This approach aims to establish a sense of trust and reliability.

Simplicity and Clarity: The advertisements emphasize the ease and simplicity of obtaining the insurance plan, highlighting the fixed rate of $9.95 without delving into the specifics of coverage limits.

Target Audience: The primary audience for these commercials is seniors, who may have concerns about the affordability and accessibility of life insurance.

Potential Misleading Aspects:

Coverage Ambiguity: While the commercials prominently display the $9.95 price tag, they often do not explicitly clarify that the coverage amount varies based on the policyholder’s age. This can create a misconception that the coverage is uniform for all.

Comparison with Other Plans: The lack of direct comparison with other insurance products in the market might lead viewers to believe that this is the most cost-effective option available, without understanding the nuances of coverage versus premium in other plans.

Guaranteed Acceptance Implications: The emphasis on guaranteed acceptance, while appealing, does not adequately address the trade-offs, such as the potential for lower coverage amounts and the absence of a medical underwriting process which could result in better rates for healthy individuals.

Testimonials and Case Studies:

Anecdotal evidence from customers who felt misled by these commercials can provide a real-world perspective on how the advertising messages are received:

Expectation versus Reality: Some customers have expressed surprise upon learning that the coverage they received was less than expected for their age group, contrary to their interpretation of the commercial’s message.

Comparative Disadvantage: Others have noted that upon further research, they found more comprehensive coverage options at competitive rates from other insurance providers, which were not evident from the Colonial Penn advertisements.

Misinterpretation of Terms: Instances where customers misunderstood the terms and conditions of the policy, assuming more extensive coverage or benefits than what was actually provided under the plan.

This analysis highlights the need for a more transparent and informative approach in advertising, ensuring that potential customers have a clear understanding of what they are purchasing and how it compares to other available options. The gap between the commercial portrayal and the actual terms of the Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan underscores the importance of thorough research and consultation before committing to any insurance product.

The Reality of Coverage versus Cost

The central appeal of the Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan lies in its seemingly affordable monthly premium. However, a deeper analysis of what $9.95 actually buys in terms of insurance coverage, and how this compares to other plans in the market, is essential to understand the real value of this offering, especially for the demographic it targets.

Get Final Expense Quotes Now!

Understanding the Coverage for $9.95

Variable Coverage: The most crucial aspect to understand is that the $9.95 premium does not translate to a fixed coverage amount. Instead, the coverage varies significantly based on the age of the policyholder at the time of purchase. Typically, the older the applicant, the less coverage they receive for the same premium.

Type of Insurance: The plan is a form of whole life insurance, which means it offers lifelong coverage and includes a cash value component, albeit growing very slowly.

Limited Death Benefit: In the initial years of the policy, the death benefit might be limited, especially if the policyholder is older. This limitation is often not explicitly communicated in the commercials.

Comparison with Other Insurance Plans:

Term Life Insurance: At similar or slightly higher monthly premiums, term life insurance policies often provide significantly higher coverage. However, these policies typically require medical underwriting and are for a specific term rather than lifetime coverage.

Whole Life Insurance: Other whole life policies in the market might offer higher coverage for a similar premium, especially for younger or healthier individuals, but they often come with a more rigorous underwriting process.

Target Demographic and Their Needs:

Senior Citizens: The primary target demographic for the Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan is senior citizens, particularly those who may not have existing life insurance and are concerned about leaving financial burdens on their families.

Inadequacy for Final Expenses: For many in this demographic, the coverage provided might be insufficient to cover basic final expenses, especially given the rising costs of funeral and burial services.

Health Status Considerations: While the plan’s guaranteed acceptance is appealing for those with health issues, healthier seniors might find better value in other insurance products that consider their health status in pricing.

In summary, while the Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan offers a low, fixed premium, the actual coverage provided can be minimal, particularly for the older applicants it targets. This disparity between cost and coverage highlights the need for consumers, especially senior citizens, to critically assess their insurance needs against what is being offered and to explore the market comprehensively to find the most suitable and beneficial life insurance policy.

Hidden Costs and Terms

In evaluating any insurance product, particularly one as widely advertised as the Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan, it’s essential to look beyond the surface-level appeal and examine the potential hidden costs, fees, and terms that might not be explicitly disclosed in the commercials. This exploration can reveal crucial details that significantly impact the policy’s value and suitability for an individual’s needs.

Potential Hidden Costs and Fees:

Cost-Per-Unit Structure: The $9.95 premium buys only one unit of coverage, and the amount of coverage per unit varies depending on the policyholder’s age, gender, and state of residence. This could mean that adequate coverage requires purchasing multiple units, substantially increasing the monthly cost.

Rate of Coverage Decrease: Some policies may have terms where the coverage amount decreases over time while the premium remains constant. This is a critical detail that might not be apparent from the commercials.

Administrative Fees: While not always the case, some policies may include administrative fees or additional charges for policy management, which are not included in the advertised premium.

Understanding the Fine Print:

Waiting Periods: Many policies, including the Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan, have a waiting period (typically two years) where the full death benefit is not payable unless the policyholder dies due to an accident. This crucial term can be easily overlooked.

Non-Guaranteed Value Growth: The cash value component of these whole life policies often grows at a non-guaranteed rate, which might be slower than expected, impacting the policy’s long-term value.

Cancellation and Refund Policies: The fine print usually contains specific terms regarding policy cancellation, potential refunds, and any penalties associated. Understanding these terms is crucial to avoid unexpected losses.

Conclusion: The Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan, like any insurance product, comes with various terms and conditions that are not always apparent in its marketing materials. These hidden costs, fees, and policy specifics, buried in the fine print, can significantly affect the overall value and effectiveness of the insurance coverage.

Consumer Feedback and Reviews

Gauging consumer feedback and reviews is a vital step in understanding the real-world impact of the Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan. These reviews often provide an unvarnished perspective on customer satisfaction and highlight areas where the plan may fall short of expectations. Additionally, it’s essential to consider any regulatory actions or lawsuits that may have arisen, as they can be indicative of systemic issues with the plan or its marketing.

Summary of Consumer Reviews and Feedback:

Coverage Versus Cost Concerns: A common thread in customer feedback is the realization that the coverage amount provided is less than expected, especially for older policyholders. This often stems from the plan’s structure, where $9.95 purchases a single unit of coverage, with the amount of coverage per unit decreasing with age.

Advertising and Reality Discrepancy: Many customers have expressed frustration that the commercials did not fully represent the terms and limitations of the policy, leading to a gap between their expectations and the actual product.

Customer Service Experience: There are mixed reviews regarding customer service experiences, with some policyholders citing difficulties in getting clear answers to their questions about policy details and others appreciating the assistance received.

Comparing Colonial Penn’s $9.95 Plan with National Companies that Allow Online Quoting

Life insurance plans like what Colonial Penn is advertising are known in the marketplace as Final Expense Insurance which is generally purchased to cover funeral and burial expenses when the insured dies. Many seniors also purchase additional coverage to cover unpaid medical expenses.

According to the National Funeral Directors Association, the average price of a funeral and burial service in 2022 was about $8,000 excluding the cost of a burial plot. Moreover, if you take into consideration today’s economy, that price is likely to go up in the future.

Below, we have listed the amount of coverage a senior male or female would obtain for the $9.95 monthly premium.

Age Male Unit of Coverage Female Unit of Coverage






We’ve also posted the monthly premium required for a Colonial Penn $9.95 plan to purchase a $10,000 Whole Life Guaranteed Issue Final Expense Policy for a for a male and female:

Age# Units Needed Male per MonthUnits NeededFemale Per Month






And last, but certainly not least, we have posted the premium required to purchase a $10,000 Whole Life Guaranteed Issue Final Expense Policy from the most competitive company.

AgeMale$9.95 PlanFemale$9.95 Plan






Get Final Expense Quotes Now!

What about the Better Business Bureau Ratings?

If you’ve taken any time to scan the internet for reviews and complaints about Colonial Penn Life Insurance, you’ve likely found a significant number of complaints against the company.

However, the Better Business Bureau has awarded Colonial Penn an A+ rating, not because they’ve satisfied all customer complaints, but because they have responded to the majority of them. Here are the most recent complaints you can find on the BBB.

Consider what is Not Said in an Insurance Commercial

Most seniors who are shopping for life insurance place the emphasis on what is said rather than was is not said. And for this reason, Colonial Penn is able to sell its overpriced $9.95 plan every day.

Many seniors miss the fact that there is a two-year waiting period before the plan will pay the death benefit for death due to natural causes.Most insurance companies allow interested shoppers to get a quote with minimal information.No other insurance company sells insurance by the unit that most shoppers can understand in the first place.And finally, if you actually visit the Colonial Penn website and fill out the information needed just to get a quote, you will be bombarded with phone calls and emails for at least six months.

To get a legitimate quote on Final Expense Insurance, simply visit our website or call us at 866-868-0099 during normal business hours.

Get Final Expense and Burial Insurance Quotes!

Make sure your surviving loved ones aren’t stuck with your final expenses. Get quotes with minimal information required.


The post How Much Coverage Do You Get with Colonial Penn $9.95 Plan? first appeared on Lifeinsure.com.

Skip to content